Back to all blog posts

The 5 Best OBGYNs In New York City

It's hard finding a good gynecologist you can trust. Good news: if you're in NYC, we've done the work for you.

The 5 Best OBGYNs In New York City

Ladies, we’ve done it again, this time in the Big Apple! After bringing you the 5 Best OBGYNs in Los Angeles, we are on the East Coast, scouring our sources and condensing our findings to find you the top 5 OBGYNs in New York City! 

As women, we know that finding a skilled and compassionate OBGYN is crucial to our health and well-being. We all want the same thing, someone who’s compassionate, highly skilled, and knows how to put their patients at ease. But with so many options out there, it can be overwhelming to know where to turn. Well, now you can turn to us to find the OBGYN that is right for you.

If you’re in a hurry, here’s the tl;dr on the best OBGYNs in NYC: 

MIDTOWN EAST (60th & Madison): Dr. Sonia Bahlani is highly regarded as the Pelvic Pain Doctor, and believes in actionable treatment plans. She can be reached at (646) 876-8838. 

GARDEN CITY, LONG ISLAND: Dr. Beth McAvey is an infertility superstar who accepts most major insurance. Make an appointment by calling  (516) 746-3633.

KIPS BAY (29th & 2nd): Dr. Clarel Antoine is an educator and advocate for safe birthing techniques & practices. Reach his office at (212) 826-3300.

UPPER EAST SIDE (80th & 3rd): Dr. Andrea M. Dobrenis emphasizes close personal relationships with patients, with a commitment to patient education. She can be reached at (646) 962-9680.

UPPER EAST SIDE (69th & York): Dr. Alexis P. Melnick is on a mission to get to create a tailored treatment plans that achieves the dream of parenthood. Reach her office at (646) 962-7650.


How We Identified The Best OBGYNs in NYC

At O Positiv, we made it our mission to champion and support women at all stages of life. Whether it's PMS Symptoms, menopause, urinary tract infection, or bloating, we've got you covered. We thought about other ways we could support you, and created our very own O Positiv OBGYN selection process by rigorously cross-examining numerical data, insider information, and hundreds of reviews. We scoured New York's concrete jungle to bring you the OBGYNs of your dream, the gems that provide exceptional care, personalized attention, and a dash of fun along the way. We have everything from the high-risk pregnancy expert to the pelvic pain guru to the infertility goddess, with accolades, awards, and years of experience under their belts. It’s time to sit back, relax, and enjoy your latte while we introduce you to your next OBGYN.

The 5 Best OBGYNs In  New York

Dr. Sofia Bahlani, top 5 OBGYN in new york city
Dr. Sonia Bahlani

Why we love her: Dr. Bahlani, aka the self-proclaimed Pelvic Pain Doctor, is the type of fun and bright OBGYN you want to follow on Instagram, and you can! Pelvicpaindoc boasts more than 24K followers, sharing posts like “Are tight pussies a thing?.”

On a mission to break the silence surrounding patients’ sexual health and pelvic pain, Dr. Bahlani focuses solely on the medical and procedural treatment of pelvic pain through her practice. After completing her OBGYN residency, she saw women suffering from pelvic pain in silence, listened to her gut, and pursued a fellowship in the urology department, working with pioneers in pelvic pain. Training in these two areas has given her a unique holistic perspective on ordinary women’s health issues.

Rating: 4.9 - 355 reviews

What patients say: 

"Professional, kind, and well knowledgeable about pelvic health, Dr. Bahlani. All of her patients received tailored care from her, and she goes above and above to give holistic care. She is a great authority in her industry, and I heartily endorse her."

"No doctor has ever spent this amount of time talking to me face to face. She heard me, she believed me, and she created an actionable treatment plan for my vaginismus. For so long, I felt like this was all in my head and something that I'd never be able to work through, but now I am hopeful and excited to move forward.  I'm so thankful. "

Address & Parking: 14 E 60th St Ste 212, New York, NY, 10022 | Parking on premises: $35  for 12h,  limited street parking
Office hours:  9AM - 5PM 
Phone number: (646) 876-8838
Accepted insurance:  None.


Dr. Beth McAvey, top 5 OBGYN in New York City
Dr. Beth McAvey

Why we love her:  Dr. McAvey is an infertility superstar. She’s double board certified in Obstetrics and Gynecology and Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, but what we love the most about her is that she’s a scholar. She’s an assistant Clinical Professor of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Reproductive Science at Mount Sinai Icahn School of Medicine.

Dr. McAvey's research has been published in the Official Journal of the
American Society for Reproductive Medicine. She also appears in numerous media outlets, including the New York Post, Newsday, and Brit. co. Dr. McAvey is a busy mother of four children and a wife to a cardiac anesthesiologist. She likes to spend time doing fun things, like seeing a Mets game or a Brooklyn Nets game.

Rating: 4.8 - 190 reviews

What patients say: 

"From the moment my husband and I walked in for our first consultation, our worries were put to rest. Dr. Mcavey is very knowledgeable and knew the exact course of action to take in order for my husband and I to receive our BFP result in just our FIRST cycle working with her and her team! We are beyond thrilled!"

"Dr. Mcavey was very informative, very patient, listened to and answered all of our questions, one of the best dr visits I’ve had in a while! I loved how we had a sit down with Dr Mcavey, then a sit down with the nurse for more information, then a sit down with a financial advisor who went over our coverage in detail. Great, great team there! Front desk staff were great over the phone and in person!"

Address & Parking: 877 Stewart Ave #24, Garden City, NY 11530 | Free parking on premises 
Office hours:  7 AM – 4PM
Phone number: (516) 746-3633
Accepted insurance:  United Healthcare, Aetna, Anthem, Cigna. PPO, HMO.


Dr. Clarel Antoine, top 5 OBGYN in NYC
Dr. Clarel Antoine

Why we love him:  Dr. Clarel speaks English, French, Haitian Creole, and Spanish. He pairs his exceptional experience with an old-fashioned fashioned bowtie. He's by far the classiest OBGYN we've met, but that's not why we picked him! Dr. Antoine is affiliated with the prestigious NYU Langone Health Tisch Hospital. He is double certified in Maternal & Fetal Medicine and Obstetrics & Gynecology and has over 47 years of experience.

When asked about his goals as an OBGYN, he answers, "I have two missions. One is to bring to providers' attention that technique matters. The second mission is to educate and advocate for women to have safe births." In addition, he is determined to eradicate complications of C-sections. 

Rating: 4.9 - 272 reviews

What patients say: 

"I've been in Dr. Antoine's care since my son's birth 18 yrs ago. All my pregnancies were complex and three ended in miscarriage. Dr. Antoine always made my husband and I feel as if we were his only patients. Now, as I enter perimenopause, my body again has it's ups and downs. There has never been a moment they have not listened to my frustrations and nurtured me toward treatments.  Simply, Dr. Antoine is THE BEST."

"Dr. Antoine is compassionate, kind and caring. He is also vigilant regarding maternal health during pregnancy, and women's health in general. What more can you ask for in a physician?"

Address & Parking: 302 E 30th St Ground Floor, New York, NY 10016 |  
Office hours: 9AM - 5PM 
Phone number: (212) 826-3300
Accepted insurance:  UnitedHealthcare Top Tier, PPO


Dr. Andrea M. Dobrenis, top 5 OBGYN in NYC
Dr. Andrea M. Dobrenis

Why we love her: Dr. Dobrenis is undoubtedly as passionate as she is skilled, when asked why she loves her job, she answers, "I love that I'm able to do the best two jobs in the world: being a mom and being an OBGYN." She is a faculty member of the prestigious Weill Cornell Medical College, one of the country's top-ranked clinical and medical research centers. In addition, she has been named one of America's Top Doctors by Castle Connolly.

Dr. Dobrenis emphasizes close personal relationships with patients, with a commitment to patient education and self-determination. Her passion for helping others has grown into a solid commitment to the full range of women's health issues and the desire to support women through all stages of life.

Rating: 4.83 - 334 reviews

What patients say: 

"She is the most amazing doctor. I have been her patient for over 25 years. She is professional, thorough, has a warm and comforting bedside manner. I can’t say enough . She delivered my son and my pregnancy, labor and birth were seamless and she made me feel calm, comfortable and extremely well taken care of!! You would be lucky to have her as your doctor!"

"Dr. Dobrenis is probably the best OBGyn in Manhattan. Not only is she an excellent doctor, but will be your advocate and friend throughout pregnancy and delivery. I had life-threatening postpartum hemorrhage after my delivery and she literally saved my life. The staff at Cornell is top notch, the facility is beautiful, you can't go wrong here."

Address & Parking: 211 East 80th Street, 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10075 |  Street parking
Office hours:  6:30AM - 5PM 
Phone number: (646) 962-9680
Accepted insurance:   United Healthcare, Aetna, Anthem, Cigna. PPO, HMO.


Dr. Alexis P Melnick, top 5 OBGYN in NYC
Dr. Alexis P. Melnick

Why we love her: Dr. Melnick has received numerous awards for her clinical excellence and surgical expertise, including the Frederick C. Holden Award for Excellence in Obstetrics & Gynecology (NYU) and the Special Resident in Minimally Invasive Surgery Award (American Association of Gynecologic Laparoscopists). We love that she pairs excellence with passion, saying her "goal as a physician is to get to know each patient individually to create a tailored treatment plan that achieves the dream of parenthood." 

In addition, she is a prolific researcher who has authored numerous peer-reviewed publications. Her current areas of interest include preimplantation genetic screening (PGS), implantation failure, and oocyte donation. Dr. Melnick speaks English and Spanish.

Rating: 5 - 314 reviews

What patients say: 

"Dr. Melnick is thorough and really gets to know her patients and their situations. She is honest and thoughtful, very responsive and always there for and available to support her patients. She also doesn’t make things any more complicated than they need to be. Highly recommend!"

"Dr. Melnick is the absolute best! She is kind, attentive, brilliant and answers any questions you may have. She takes her time and makes you feel so comfortable, I wouldn’t go to anyone else, and feel so incredibly lucky to have found her. The atmosphere in her office is welcoming and attentive, I will sincerely miss them when we finish treatment. You are in the best hands with her!"

Address & Parking: 1305 York Avenue, 6th Floor, New York, NY 10021| Street parking 
Office hours:  6:30AM - 5PM 
Phone number: (646) 962-7650
Accepted insurance: United Healthcare, Aetna, Anthem, Cigna. PPO, HMO.

We're always looking to meet great OBGYNs. If you're a practitioner who would like to learn more about O Positiv, please reach out to us at


At O Positiv, we empower women by providing natural products that help fight and alleviate an array of symptoms. From PMS symptoms & menopause to urinary tract & vaginal health concerns, we've got you covered. Remember, with a good OBGYN, a balanced diet, and quality supplements, you're on your way to becoming your best self!

Shop Now

Shop The Story